Explain the difference between a Control Valve and a Shut-Off Valve and give an example of when you would use each

  • An Industrial process control system consists of dozens of various types of valves for process application.
  • Each & every valve type functions for a specific purpose, but there is a slight confusion in differentiation among them so most of them fall into trouble in differentiating between control valves and shut-off valves.
  • These Control valves & Shut-off valves set out different occasions depending on the degree of control required for your control system. 
  • Let us see what are Control valves & Shut-off valves with an example of each.

What is a Control Valve?

Explain the difference between a Control Valve and a Shut-Off Valve and give an example of when you would use each2
  • Basically, we all know that a control valve is a power-operated field instrument that controls, & regulates the fluid flow according to the process condition within the processing system. 
  • The process fluids such as water, gas, oil, steam, and other industrial process fluids.
  • The control valve is the critical part of a control loop, & is considered an essential instance of a final control element in today’s process industry.
  • The shut-off capability of the control valve is not as accurate as that of the shut-off valve.
  • The Control Valve consists of Valve and the Actuator 
  • A control valve functions by using electric, pneumatic, or hydraulic signals.
  • An electronic controller such as a PLC sends an electronic signal to the control valve to control the flow rate of process fluid in order.

What is a Shut-Off Valve?

Explain the difference between a Control Valve and a Shut-Off Valve and give an example of when you would use each 1
  • A shut-off valve, as the name suggests, is primarily designed to completely stop the flow of fluids.
  • Shut-off valves are intended to safely restrict or safely permit the flow of hazardous fluids, or any external gases.
  • These Shut-off valves restrict the compressed air flow that is used in an industrial automation process or isolate sub-systems when not functioning.
  • The common names for shut-off valves are lockout valve, cut-off valve, shutdown valve, an emergency shutdown valve, a ball valve, or an exhausting ball valve.
  • These shut-off valves are also a member of the large valve family, among them we have the Thermostatic (Temperature Control) Valve, Pressure Control Valve, Solenoid Valve, Instrument Valves, ball valve, and so on.

Differentiate between Control Valve, & Shut-Off Valve

AspectControl ValveShut-Off Valve
Abbreviation CV, in short, it can be LV, FV, PVXV
Primary PurposeMaintain desired conditions within a systemIsolate sections for maintenance or safety
Function Controls, & Regulates the flow w.r.t process conditionServes as a fully opening valve or closing valve.
Shutoff Capability Not Good like Shut-Off ValveBetter Shut off Capability 
StructureControl valves are equipped with globe-type bodies with position response assembled with an accurate positioning device.Shut-Off valves are equipped with solenoid valves and cut-off accessories like a limit switch.
Installation pointControl Valves are installed at the downstream side of the Shut-Off Valve, it is installed in closed-loop control.Shut-Off Valves are installed at the upstream side of the Control Valves, it is installed in open-loop control.
Type of Control LoopClosed-Loop ControlOpen-Loop Control.
Type of ControlThis controls, regulates, & modulates any type of control such as Pressure Control, Flow Control, Temperature Control, & Level Control.Controls the flow of process fluid.
Response Faster Response with High Accuracy for opening or closing action.Slower Response with Less Accuracy compared to Control Valve
AutomationOften part of automated systems for precisionManual or automated operation
Control ElementAnalog type Control ElementDigital type Control Element or Manual Control
ComplexityContains intricate mechanisms for controlSimpler mechanisms, easier maintenance
MaintenanceRequires periodic maintenance for optimal functionLess frequent maintenance is often sufficient

An example of the use of a Control Valve

  • Control valves in Oil & Gas, Food processing industries, & Power Plants control & regulate the flow of Gas, Oil, Water, Steam & other process fluids.
  • But Oil & Gas production units utilize control valves of the High-Pressure range in the following applications. 
  • Liquid Dump Valve on a separator.
  • Gas Back Pressure on any production vessel.
  • Pressure Reduction on a compressor.
  • Boiler Operation: Consider a steam boiler used in a power plant to generate electricity. The steam produced is used to turn turbines.
  • Precise Regulation: To optimize efficiency, a control valve is placed in the steam line. It’s linked to a controller that monitors parameters like steam pressure and demand.
  • Variable Opening: As power demand changes, the control valve adjusts its opening. This modulates steam flow into the turbine, matching generation to demand.
  • Pressure Control: If steam pressure rises, the control valve can throttle the flow, preventing excessive pressure that could damage the system.
  • Energy Efficiency: The control valve ensures the right amount of steam enters the turbine, preventing wastage and maintaining efficiency.
  • Load Changes: When power demand decreases, the control valve reduces steam flow, preventing turbine over-speeding and maintaining stable operation.
  • Safety Measures: In emergencies, the control valve can be used to rapidly shut off steam flow to prevent system failures.
  • Automated System: Modern control valves are often integrated into automated systems, enhancing precision and responsiveness.

An example of the use of a Shut-Off valve     

  • Planned Maintenance: In a natural gas distribution network, shut-off valves are strategically placed along pipelines to enable maintenance.
  • Isolation for Repair: When maintenance or repairs are needed, the shut-off valve upstream of the work area is closed, stopping gas flow to that section.
  • Safety and Repair: This closure ensures safety for maintenance crews by preventing gas leaks during repairs or component replacements.
  • Testing and Completion: After repairs, thorough checks are done to ensure no leaks. Once deemed safe, the shut-off valve is reopened, restoring gas flow to the repaired segment.
  • Emergency Situations: In case of leaks, fires, or other emergencies, shut-off valves enable rapid isolation of affected sections to prevent the escalation of hazards.
  • Process Upsets: During unexpected process upsets, shut-off valves can swiftly halt the flow to prevent accidents and mitigate damages.
  • System Integrity: Shut-off valves allow for systematic shutdowns, reducing the risk of catastrophic failures in large systems.
  • Isolation of Hazards: When dealing with toxic or dangerous substances, shut-off valves offer a way to isolate and contain potential hazards.
  • Regulatory Compliance: Shut-off valves are often mandated by safety regulations to provide a means of isolating equipment or sections when needed.     

What are examples of shut-off valves?

  • Basically, the Shut-off valve is less accurate compared to the control valve.
  • It either allows for unrestricted flow or restricts the flow completely. 
  • Shut-off valves are available in various styles like Ball, Plug, Butterfly, Gate, and Globe Valves.
  • An example of a shut-off valve is part of a ring main system.

What is the difference between a Control Valve & Shut-Off Valve?

  • Most technicians fall into trouble differentiating control valves and shut-off valves. 
  • Usually in industrial applications these Control valves and shut-off valves serve different functions that depend on the degree of control required for our process control system refer to the table shown above for differences. 

What is the use of a Shut-off Valve?

  • Shut-off valves are intended to safely restrict or permit the flow of hazardous fluids or external gases. 
  • These valves block the compressed instrument air within the industrial & automation process. These valves isolate the sub-systems when not used.

What material is used in making Shut-Off valves?

  • Shut-Off is made of Brass for better Durability, & Reliability used as an essential fixture.
  • For some applications, these valves are made of plastic or polypropylene.

Sundareswaran Iyalunaidu

With over 24 years of dedicated experience, I am a seasoned professional specializing in the commissioning, maintenance, and installation of Electrical, Instrumentation and Control systems. My expertise extends across a spectrum of industries, including Power stations, Oil and Gas, Aluminium, Utilities, Steel and Continuous process industries. Tweet me @sundareshinfohe

Related Articles

Back to top button