Root Cause Analysis of PLC Remote I/O Panel (Point I/O Panel) Cards Failure Issues

- Background of the Incident
- Key Components of the PLC Remote I/O Control Panel
- Environmental Conditions and Installation Setup
- Field vs. Rack Room Installations
- Panel Sealing and Protection Measures
- Initial Hypotheses
- Hypothesis 1: Quality of Components
- Hypothesis 2: Moisture Ingress
- Hypothesis 3: Excessive Heat
- Verification via Thermography
- Thermography Findings
- Understanding the Impact of Heat on Electronics
- Solution: Installation of a Vortex Cooler
- Vortex Cooler Implementation
- Cost-Effectiveness and Long-Term Benefits
- Lessons Learned
- Regular Thermographic Inspections
- Importance of Environmental Monitoring
- Preventive Maintenance and Cleaning
- What is a Vortex Cooler?
- What is the Principle of Vortex Air Cooler?
- How Does a Vortex System Work?
- How Does a Vortex Cooler Work?
- Advantages of Using a Vortex Cooler
Background of the Incident
PLC Remote I/O Panels (Point I/O) are essential for allowing continuous connection between the central control system and field devices in industrial automation. These panels contain a variety of electronic parts that are necessary for the real-time operation and control of plant processes, including communication modules, signal conditioning barriers, and I/O cards.
An I/O Panel installed in a process plant started to see frequent card failures in this case study. This panel was a component of a field installation that was set up on-site and intended to withstand a range of environmental factors. According to the engineers, the problems started with signal barriers malfunctioning and then spread to the I/O cards. Failures increased in frequency during the second year of operation, disrupting operations and necessitating expensive repairs and replacements.
Key Components of the PLC Remote I/O Control Panel

To understand the impact of the failures, it’s essential to recognize the panel’s components and their roles:
- I/O Cards: These facilitate input and output signals between field instruments and the control system.
- Communication Modules: Ensure data transfer within the panel and to other control units.
- Signal Barriers: Protect circuits by isolating hazardous areas and preventing accidental surges.
- Power Supply Units: Provide stable voltage and current to the entire system.
- Relays: Control electrical circuits by opening and closing contacts in another circuit.
Each of these components is integral to the panel’s operation, and failure in any one of them could compromise the functionality of the entire system.
Click here for Understanding Remote I/O in PLC Control Systems
Environmental Conditions and Installation Setup
Variable weather conditions can have a big impact on electronic systems installed in field locations. The temperature of this specific panel fluctuated between 10°C during the colder months of December and January to 35°C during the hotter months of May and June. The enclosed atmosphere inside the panel may cause heat accumulation even though these temperatures are within normal levels for field installations.
Field vs. Rack Room Installations
The environment in which PLC Remote I/O Panels are installed significantly impacts their performance and reliability. The key distinction lies between rack rooms, which provide controlled conditions, and field installations, which face more challenging environments.
Environmental Conditions of Rack Room Installations
- Controlled Climate: Rack rooms maintain stable temperatures (typically 18°C to 24°C) and humidity levels (45% to 55%). This regulation minimizes risks like overheating and condensation, which can damage electronic components.
- Air Quality and ESD Protection: Advanced air filtration systems help keep dust at bay, while ESD mitigation measures, such as static-dissipative flooring, protect sensitive equipment.
Environmental Conditions of Field Installations
- Variable Conditions: Field panels are exposed to temperature fluctuations, ranging from freezing to over 35°C, along with dust, moisture, and corrosive substances.
- Weather-Resistant Design: These panels must be ruggedly constructed, using materials like stainless steel to withstand elements such as rain, snow, and humidity.
Panel Sealing and Protection Measures
Despite these challenges, this panel was well-protected with effective sealing measures. The following precautions were taken:
- Sealed Openings: Silastic sealant was applied around any openings to prevent dust and moisture ingress.
- Cable Glands and Blind Plugs: All cable entries were properly fitted with glands, and any unused entries were capped with blind plugs to maintain the panel’s integrity.
Initial Hypotheses
The Instrumentation Engineers began their investigation by hypothesizing several potential causes for the component failures.
The process involved systematically ruling out possibilities based on evidence and examination.
Click here for Common Causes of Programmable Logic Controller(PLC) Failure and Mitigation Strategies
Hypothesis 1: Quality of Components
- Initially, engineers suspected that the failures might be due to defective components. However, it was quickly determined that the components were sourced from reputable manufacturers and were operating successfully in other locations.
- Furthermore, records indicated that components from the same production lot installed elsewhere did not exhibit similar failures.
Hypothesis 2: Moisture Ingress
- Given the outdoor installation, the possibility of moisture ingress was a major concern. Moisture can lead to corrosion, short circuits, and damage to electronic components.
- The engineers inspected the panel for any signs of moisture or condensation.
- However, they found no traces of water or corrosion. The panel’s sealing was verified, confirming it was tightly closed and effectively weatherproofed.
Click here for Panel Door Earth Bonding Procedure: Ensuring Safety and Reliability
Hypothesis 3: Excessive Heat
- Engineers began to consider that heat buildup within the panel might be causing the failures.
- Unlike climate-controlled rack rooms, field installations experience more temperature swings, making them susceptible to heat issues.
- Electronic components in an enclosed panel can generate heat, leading to localized hot spots that aren’t always obvious.
- Initially, engineers dismissed heat as a cause since overall environmental temperatures seemed moderate.
- Still, given the recurring failures, they decided to investigate further to confirm or rule out heat as the potential root cause.
Verification via Thermography
To validate the hypothesis of heat buildup, the team conducted a thermographic survey of the panel. Thermography is a non-invasive diagnostic tool that detects temperature variations and can reveal potential hot spots within electronic systems.
Thermography Findings
- The thermography scan revealed several hot spots reaching temperatures up to 43°C, even when the external ambient temperature was only 20°C.
- These findings were significant as they demonstrated that the enclosed panel environment contributed to an internal temperature rise of over 20°C.
- Given that the external temperature could reach as high as 35°C, the internal temperature could potentially exceed 55°C, posing a serious risk to electronic components not rated for such conditions.
Understanding the Impact of Heat on Electronics
- Excessive heat can accelerate the degradation of electronic components, reducing their lifespan and reliability.
- In this case, the repeated heating and cooling cycles likely caused thermal stress on the signal barriers and I/O cards, leading to premature failures.
- Components like capacitors and semiconductors are especially vulnerable, as they may suffer from dielectric breakdown and altered performance characteristics under prolonged heat exposure.
Solution: Installation of a Vortex Cooler

To address the overheating issue, the engineers decided to install a vortex cooler within the panel. This cooling solution offers several advantages for field installations where conventional air conditioning is impractical or costly.
Vortex Cooler Implementation

- The vortex cooler was connected to a compressed air supply.
- It works by converting compressed air into a cool air stream, which is directed into the panel to lower its internal temperature.
- After a few hours of operation, the hotspot temperature dropped from 43°C to 24°C, effectively mitigating the risk of overheating.
Cost-Effectiveness and Long-Term Benefits

- The vortex cooler’s installation cost was approximately 19,000 Rs.(226.11 United States Dollar) While this may seem like a significant investment, the reduction in card failures resulted in substantial cost savings over time.
- By preventing frequent component replacements and reducing maintenance downtimes, the plant achieved increased uptime and reliability, demonstrating the vortex cooler’s long-term value.
Lessons Learned
This case study provide valuable insights that can guide future installations and improve maintenance practices for automation panels, especially those exposed to harsh field conditions. By implementing these lessons, engineers and maintenance teams can significantly enhance the reliability and lifespan of electronic components.
Regular Thermographic Inspections
One of the key takeaways from this incident is the importance of routine thermographic inspections. Thermography can quickly identify potential hotspots and overheating issues before they lead to serious component failures. By using infrared cameras to scan the panel and its components, maintenance teams can detect abnormal temperature rises in specific areas that may not be obvious during regular visual inspections.
Preventive Action:
- Early detection through thermography allows for timely interventions, such as improving cooling systems, installing vortex coolers, or enhancing natural ventilation.
Scheduled Checks:
- Creating regular thermographic scans into the maintenance schedule ensures that any developing issues can be addressed before they escalate, reducing the risk of unexpected failures and costly downtime.
Importance of Environmental Monitoring
Panels installed in the field are constantly exposed to fluctuating environmental conditions, making continuous environmental monitoring essential.
Tracking key parameters like temperature, humidity, and the presence of contaminants (dust, moisture) can provide critical insights into how well the panel is performing under stress.
Early Warning System:
- Installing sensors inside the panel to monitor these environmental factors can act as an early warning system. If temperatures rise above a certain threshold or moisture levels increase, automated alerts can prompt immediate action, allowing engineers to address the situation before damage occurs.
Customized Solutions:
- Based on the data gathered from environmental monitoring, custom cooling or protection measures can be tailored to specific installations. For example, in high-temperature areas, a more robust cooling solution like a vortex cooler might be necessary.
Preventive Maintenance and Cleaning
Preventive maintenance and regular cleaning play a crucial role in ensuring the longevity of electronic components inside automation panels. Dust, debris, and even insects can accumulate inside panels over time, particularly in field installations.
These particles act as insulation, trapping heat and restricting airflow, which can exacerbate overheating problems.
- Routine Cleaning: Periodic cleaning of the panel’s interior is essential to prevent dust buildup that could block ventilation or settle on components, causing insulation and further heat retention.
- Airflow Optimization: Ensuring that fans and ventilation systems remain unobstructed allows for optimal airflow, keeping temperatures in check and preventing localized hotspots.
- Component Longevity: Preventive maintenance, including regular visual inspections, thermographic checks, and environmental monitoring, significantly extends the lifespan of electronic components, reduces failures, and minimizes unplanned downtime.
Click here for Quiz on Understanding PLC Hardware Components
What is a Vortex Cooler?

A vortex cooler is an industrial cooling device that uses compressed air to create a temperature differential, making it ideal for environments where traditional air conditioning is not feasible or effective.
This device is commonly used in control panels, where overheating of electronic components can be a serious issue. Vortex coolers are reliable, low-maintenance, and operate without any moving parts, making them suitable for harsh industrial environment.
What is the Principle of Vortex Air Cooler?


The principle behind the vortex cooler is based on vortex tube technology, which relies on compressed air and the separation of air molecules through a vortex effect. When compressed air enters the vortex tube, it is forced to spin at very high speeds. Due to this rapid spinning, the heavier, warmer air molecules move to the outer part of the vortex, while the lighter, cooler molecules remain in the center. This creates a temperature gradient, where the hot air is expelled from one side, and the cold air is directed to the area needing cooling.
How Does a Vortex System Work?
A vortex system works by creating a spinning motion inside a cylindrical tube, which separates compressed air into two streams with different temperatures. The system exploits the fact that when air is spun rapidly, the centrifugal force causes a split in temperature. The hot air is discharged through one port, and cold air is channeled to the desired cooling location.
This cooling method is highly efficient, as it requires only compressed air to function no electricity, moving parts, or complex machinery are needed. Vortex systems are especially useful in situations where space is limited or where maintaining a stable temperature in an enclosed area, like an automation panel, is critical.
Click here for Ingress Protection IP and NEMA Ratings: Selecting the Right Enclosure for Your Application
How Does a Vortex Cooler Work?
A vortex cooler operates by using compressed air to create a swirling effect inside a cylindrical chamber. This swirling motion, or vortex, separates the air into hot and cold streams.
- Compressed Air Input: Compressed air enters the vortex cooler, forcing the air into a tight spiral pattern.
- Vortex Formation: As the air spins rapidly, centrifugal forces push the warmer, denser air molecules to the outer edges of the chamber, while the cooler, lighter air molecules remain near the center.
- Air Separation: This spinning air creates two streams hot air exits through an exhaust port, and the cooler air is directed into the area requiring cooling, such as a control panel.
- Cooling Output: The cooler’s output temperature can be regulated by adjusting the airflow and internal valve, allowing precise control of the cooling effect.
Advantages of Using a Vortex Cooler
- No Moving Parts: With no moving parts, vortex coolers require minimal maintenance and are highly reliable.
- Low Operating Costs: Since they only require compressed air, there are no electricity costs, making them energy-efficient.
- Durability: Designed for industrial environments, vortex coolers are resistant to dust, moisture, and vibrations.
Click here for Programmable Logic Controller (PLC) Program Backup Checklist