Intrinsic Safety Calculation for Instrumentation Engineers: Complete Guide

Intrinsic safety calculation is an essential part of instrumentation design for hazardous areas where flammable gases, vapours or combustible dust may create an explosion risk. It verifies whether the field instrument, safety barrier or galvanic isolator, and connecting cable meet the applicable electrical compatibility requirements.

This guide explains how to perform intrinsic safety entity parameter calculations, verify voltage, current and power compatibility, calculate cable capacitance and inductance, and determine whether an instrument loop is suitable for the proposed installation.

The procedure is useful for instrumentation design engineers, EPC teams, hazardous area specialists, commissioning engineers and maintenance professionals working in refineries, oil and gas facilities, petrochemical plants and other process industries.

Purpose of Intrinsic Safety

Strict safety measures must be taken when instruments are utilized in areas with flammable gases, vapors, liquids, combustible dust, or ignitable fibers. There are several different protection strategies available, each with its own set of benefits and drawbacks.

Among these strategies, intrinsic safety is the most dependable and simple to implement. It ensures that equipment and wiring in hazardous areas do not discharge enough electrical or thermal energy to ignite the hazardous atmosphere, even under normal or extraordinary circumstances.

Intrinsic safety is achieved by limiting the energy available to electrical equipment in the potentially hazardous region. This limitation ensures that the energy remains below the environmental igniting threshold.

According to Article 504 of the National Electrical Code (NEC), an intrinsically safe system is “an assembly of interconnected intrinsically safe apparatus, associated apparatus, and interconnecting cables where the hazardous location circuits are intrinsically safe.”

Components of an Intrinsically Safe Loop

An intrinsically safe loop consists of the following components:

  • Non-simple devices installed in hazardous areas.
  • These devices store or generate energy, and hence, must be certified as intrinsically safe.
  • Example: Transmitters, flowmeters.
  • Those devices that are installed in safe regions and serve as an interface between safe and hazardous zones.
  • Example: Intrinsic safety barriers, isolators.
  • Copper conductor cables, either single-pair or multi-pair.
  • These cables must be carefully selected to ensure compatibility with the other components.

Intrinsic safety (IS) is a crucial safety concept for preventing electrical equipment from igniting hazardous areas, such as those found in industries dealing with flammable gases, vapors, or dust. It involves designing equipment and wiring to limit energy levels (voltage, current, capacitance, and inductance) so that they are below the ignition thresholds of explosive atmospheres.

Entity parameters are assigned to both intrinsically safe apparatus (instruments) and associated apparatus (safety barriers). These parameters ensure compatibility and safety in an intrinsically safe loop.

Understanding Intrinsic Safety (IS) Parameters and Certification Process 1
  • Vmax (Ui): Maximum voltage that can be safely applied to the instrument.
  • Imax (Ii): Maximum current that can be safely applied to the instrument.
  • Ci: Internal capacitance of the instrument.
  • Li: Internal inductance of the instrument.
Understanding Intrinsic Safety (IS) Parameters and Certification Process 2
  • Voc (Uo): Maximum open-circuit voltage under fault conditions.
  • Isc (Io): Maximum short-circuit current under fault conditions.
  • Ca: Maximum allowable external capacitance.
  • La: Maximum allowable external inductance.

Click here to know more about Difference Between Intrinsically Safe and Explosion-Proof

Independent certification authorities must evaluate and approve intrinsically safe equipment before it can be used in hazardous environments. The customer should specify what type of approval is necessary for a certain application. 

The most prevalent certifying agencies are:

CountryAgency
USAFM, UL
CanadaCSA
Great BritainBASEEFA
FranceLCIE
GermanyPTB
ItalyCESI
BelgiumINEX

Note:It is important to note that approval from any of the European agencies listed above provides a CENELEC approval, which enables the units to be regarded approved in a number of European nations.

There are two main certification concepts for equipment used in hazardous environments:

Specifies the specific part numbers and products that may be utilized in the loop. No variations from these units are permitted.

Specifies the requirements that any authorized intrinsic safety barrier must meet. This approach allows customers to choose barriers from various approved manufacturers as long as certain criteria are met. According to the ENTITY approval concept, two things (an instrument and a barrier) can be connected if the following conditions are satisfied:

Interconnection of Intrinsically Safe Equipment  2

Before connecting a field instrument to an intrinsic safety barrier or galvanic isolator, compare the certified output parameters of the associated apparatus with the certified input parameters of the field instrument.

The following five checks form the basic entity compatibility assessment.

ParameterRequired conditionMeaning
VoltageUo ≤ UiBarrier output voltage must not exceed the instrument input voltage rating
CurrentIo ≤ IiBarrier output current must not exceed the instrument input current rating
PowerPo ≤ PiBarrier output power must not exceed the instrument input power rating
CapacitanceCi + Ccable ≤ CoInstrument and cable capacitance must remain within the permitted limit
InductanceLi + Lcable ≤ LoInstrument and cable inductance must remain within the permitted limit

Here, Uo, Io, Po, Co and Lo are the certified output parameters of the associated apparatus. Ui, Ii, Pi, Ci and Li are the certified input parameters of the intrinsically safe field instrument.

The loop can pass these basic entity checks only when all applicable conditions are satisfied. Additional restrictions in equipment certificates, control drawings, gas group requirements and applicable installation standards must also be verified before the design is approved.

Uo: Maximum Output Voltage

Uo is the maximum certified output voltage of the associated apparatus, such as an intrinsic safety barrier or galvanic isolator. It must not exceed the Ui rating of the connected field instrument.

Io is the maximum certified output current of the associated apparatus. It must be less than or equal to the Ii rating of the field instrument.

Po is the maximum certified output power available from the associated apparatus. It must not exceed the Pi rating of the field instrument.

Co specifies the permitted external capacitance for the associated apparatus under its certification conditions. The combined capacitance of the field instrument and connecting cable must remain within this limit.

Lo specifies the permitted external inductance for the associated apparatus under its certification conditions. The combined inductance of the field instrument and connecting cable must remain within this limit.

Ui is the maximum certified input voltage of the intrinsically safe field instrument. It must be greater than or equal to the barrier Uo value.

Ii is the maximum certified input current of the field instrument. It must be greater than or equal to the barrier Io value.

Pi is the maximum certified input power of the field instrument. It must be greater than or equal to the barrier Po value.

Ci is the internal capacitance and Li is the internal inductance specified for the field instrument. These values must be included when calculating the total capacitance and inductance of the loop.

The connecting cable contributes capacitance and inductance to an intrinsically safe loop. These values must be included when checking the compatibility of the barrier and field instrument.

Cable capacitance = Cable capacitance per unit length × Cable length

Total loop capacitance = Instrument capacitance + Cable capacitance

The required condition is:

Ci + Ccable ≤ Co

Cable inductance = Cable inductance per unit length × Cable length

Total loop inductance = Instrument inductance + Cable inductance

The required condition is:

Li + Lcable ≤ Lo

Use the actual cable capacitance and inductance values from the cable datasheet whenever available. If those values are unavailable, use substitute values only when permitted by the applicable standard, equipment documentation and project requirements.

Consider a pressure transmitter installed in a hazardous area and connected to a certified intrinsic safety barrier in the safe area.

ParameterValue
Ui28 V
Ii110 mA
Pi0.80 W
Ci0.05 µF
Li0.10 mH
ParameterValue
Uo24 V
Io100 mA
Po0.60 W
Co0.083 µF
Lo0.20 mH

Cable length = 500 ft

Cable capacitance = 60 pF per ft

Cable inductance = 0.20 µH per ft

Uo ≤ Ui

24 V ≤ 28 V

Result: Pass

Io ≤ Ii

100 mA ≤ 110 mA

Result: Pass

Po ≤ Pi

0.60 W ≤ 0.80 W

Result: Pass

Cable capacitance = 500 × 60 pF

Cable capacitance = 30,000 pF = 0.030 µF

Total capacitance = 0.050 + 0.030

Total capacitance = 0.080 µF

Compare with Co:

0.080 µF ≤ 0.083 µF

Result: Pass

Cable inductance = 500 × 0.20 µH

Cable inductance = 100 µH = 0.10 mH

Total inductance = 0.10 + 0.10

Total inductance = 0.20 mH

Compare with Lo:

0.20 mH ≤ 0.20 mH

Result: Pass at the stated limit

All five basic entity parameter checks satisfy the stated limits for this illustrative example. However, the inductance result has no margin, and the complete loop must still be verified against the actual equipment certificates, cable data, applicable restrictions and approved control drawing before acceptance.

The available capacitance and inductance limits can be used to estimate the maximum cable length permitted by each parameter.

Maximum cable length = (Co − Ci) ÷ Cable capacitance per unit length

Maximum cable length = (Lo − Li) ÷ Cable inductance per unit length

The permitted length must satisfy both applicable limits. Use consistent units throughout the calculation.

For example, if the capacitance calculation permits 400 metres and the inductance calculation permits 300 metres, the inductance limit is more restrictive. The maximum permitted length cannot exceed 300 metres on the basis of these two calculations alone.

The final design must also account for the cable manufacturer’s data, equipment certification conditions and any additional circuit restrictions. A mathematical cable length result does not by itself establish intrinsic safety compliance.

MistakeWhy It Matters
Reversing Uo and Ui comparisonCan lead to an incorrect voltage compatibility decision
Comparing normal operating current instead of certified IoUses the wrong current parameter
Ignoring Po and PiLeaves power compatibility unverified
Omitting cable capacitanceUnderestimates total loop capacitance
Omitting cable inductanceUnderestimates total loop inductance
Mixing nF and µFCan create a significant calculation error
Mixing µH and mHCan produce an incorrect inductance result
Using assumed cable data for final approvalMay misrepresent the actual cable characteristics
Ignoring certificate restrictionsCan invalidate an otherwise acceptable basic comparison
Checking only the barrier and transmitterLeaves other installation requirements unverified
Ignoring signal compatibilityMay result in an unsuitable interface for the instrument
Failing to update loop documentationLeaves the approved design inconsistent with the installation

Always use certified parameter values and verify the complete loop before approving the installation.

Entity parameter compatibility is an important part of intrinsic safety design, but it is not the only requirement.

Instrumentation engineers should also verify:

  1. The hazardous area classification and applicable equipment protection level.
  2. The gas group and temperature classification.
  3. The certification of the field instrument and associated apparatus.
  4. Cable segregation, routing and installation requirements.
  5. Grounding requirements for the selected barrier type.
  6. Compatibility with the required 4 to 20 mA, HART or other signal function.
  7. Any additional capacitance, inductance or resistance restrictions stated in the certificates.
  8. The approved control drawing and system documentation.
  9. Compliance with the applicable hazardous area design and installation standards.

A loop that passes the five basic entity checks must not automatically be considered approved. The complete installation must meet the requirements of the applicable certificates, standards and project documentation.

Click here for Why Choose Intrinsic Safety (IS) for Hazardous Area Instrumentation?

Intrinsic safety calculation verifies the compatibility of a field instrument, associated apparatus and connecting cable for a hazardous area loop. It includes entity parameter checks and other applicable installation requirements.

The five basic checks are voltage, current, power, capacitance and inductance. The conditions are Uo ≤ Ui, Io ≤ Ii, Po ≤ Pi, Ci + Ccable ≤ Co and Li + Lcable ≤ Lo.

Ui is the maximum certified input voltage of the field instrument, while Uo is the maximum certified output voltage of the associated apparatus. The required condition is Uo ≤ Ui.

Ii is the maximum certified input current of the field instrument, while Io is the maximum certified output current of the associated apparatus. The required condition is Io ≤ Ii.

Ci is the internal capacitance of the field instrument, while Co is the maximum permitted external capacitance of the associated apparatus. Instrument and cable capacitance together must not exceed Co.

Li is the internal inductance of the field instrument, while Lo is the maximum permitted external inductance of the associated apparatus. Instrument and cable inductance together must not exceed Lo.

Multiply the cable capacitance per unit length by the installed cable length. Add the result to the field instrument capacitance and compare the total with Co.

Multiply the cable inductance per unit length by the installed cable length. Add the result to the field instrument inductance and compare the total with Lo.

Yes, if the transmitter, associated apparatus, cable and complete loop meet the applicable intrinsic safety requirements. A 4 to 20 mA signal alone does not establish intrinsic safety.

Both can serve as associated apparatus in suitable intrinsically safe circuits, but their electrical isolation and grounding arrangements differ. Selection must follow the equipment certification and application requirements.

Yes. A loop may satisfy voltage, current and power limits but exceed the permitted capacitance or inductance limits. Every applicable check must be satisfied.

IEC 60079 series standards address equipment protection and hazardous area installation requirements, including intrinsic safety equipment and installations. Confirm the applicable editions and project requirements before approving a design.

Read More

Recent